Rabu, 01 Februari 2012

4

Which Race "Owns" This Name?

Dear Name Lady, I'm expecting my first child, a boy, and my husband and I both really like the name Desmond. My mother-in-law is set against it, since Desmond is a "black" name. (I'm white and my husband is Latino.) I think she believes that because the only Desmond she knows is Bishop Tutu. Is there any validity to her argument? Do certain groups own names? - Frustrated Daughter-in-Law
You've asked two questions here. One is specific and straightforward, the other broad, complex and contentious. Let's warm up with the simple one: is Desmond an exclusively "black" name?
Desmond is an Irish surname and given name with a long history of use in Ireland, England and beyond. Yes, it has been popular with families of African descent around the world. Prominent black Desmonds include Jamaican ska legend Desmond Dekker and American football player Desmond Howard, as well as South African Bishop Tutu. Yet you'll find plenty of white Desmonds around the globe as well, such as James Bond actor Desmond Llewelyn, profesional wrestler Desmond Wolfe and Lost character Desmond Hume. The name is a distinguished classic, and if you love it you should bestow it on your son with pride.
Now for the tough part. Can a name ever "belong" to a particular group of people, so that it's inappropriate for use by others? I believe so, yes -- but not in the way your mother-in-law is thinking.
Names often hold deep meaning within a culture or religion. In rare cases, those meanings are so sacred or sensitive that outsiders' use of them can feel like an affront. For instance, I think most would agree that the name Mohammed belongs to the people of Islam. Giving that name to a Christian or Jewish child just because you like the sound of it would be inappropriate.
A name could be considered to "belong" to a people even if they don't use it as a given name themselves. Many Native Americans object to the adoption of tribe and nation names like Dakota and Cheyenne as personal names. Similarly, observant Jews often take exception with the use of Cohen -- a surname and title indicating the hereditary priestly line -- as a first name.
But does a group "own" a name simply because that group uses it the most? I believe not.
Suppose the name you liked really were uniquely African-American. Perhaps instead of Desmond, you were considering DeShaun. Would people reading that name assume your son was African-American? Probably. Would the name choice be inappropriate or offensive? No, I can't imagine so. In this nation of Irish Gabriellas and Italian Aidans, most names are, happily, open to all comers.

3 komentar:

  1. good to read about you and your family.i have seen many people with the name desmond in my area

    BalasHapus
  2. finally what name you are going to give to your child? i am waiting to see....

    BalasHapus
  3. what ever the race it may be but the name you have choose is really nice...

    BalasHapus